Ohio Sandwich Restaurants

Visiting Ohio? At least a few of these Ohio sandwich restaurants should be on your itinerary. Sandwich lovers get your appetites ready to be wowed when visiting any of these spots in the Buckeye State.

List of Ohio Sandwich Restaurants

1. Diamond Deli (Akron) – Known for their overstuffed pastrami on rye with Swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing. We visited here years ago, and they are delish!

2. Katzinger’s Delicatessen (Columbus) – Famous for their Reuben sandwiches and other classic deli creations.  

3. Larder Delicatessen and Bakery (Cleveland) – Famous for their smoked meat sandwiches, like pastrami on rye.  

4. Melt Bar and Grilled (Various Locations) – Famous for their gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches, like the "Parmageddon" with pierogies and kraut.  

5. Momocho (Cleveland) – Celebrated for their Mexican tortas, like the "Carnitas Torta."  

6. Primanti Bros. (Youngstown) – Known for their Pittsburgh-style sandwiches with fries and coleslaw stuffed inside.  

7. Swenson’s Drive-In (Akron) – While more of a burger joint, their "Galley Boy" is a must-try sandwich. We’ve also visited here and tried them. When in Akron go to Swenson’s

8. The 5th Street Pub (Perrysburg) – Known for their Italian-inspired sandwiches, like the "Meatball Sub."  

9. The B Spot (Various Locations) – Famous for their "Fat Doug" sandwich with pastrami, coleslaw, and Swiss cheese.  

10. The Black Pig (Cleveland) – Famous for their pork belly sandwiches.  

11. The Blue Door Café & Bakery (Cuyahoga Falls) – Known for their croissant breakfast sandwiches. Pretty swanky - check the hours. And the days. 

12. The Brown Bag Deli (Columbus) – Famous for their "Turkey Reuben" and other deli-style sandwiches.  

13. The Buckeye Express Diner (Bellville) – Celebrated for their Ohio-themed sandwiches, like the "Buckeye Burger."  

14. The Cornerstone Deli & Café (Athens) – Famous for their "Cornerstone Club" sandwich.  

15. The Crest Gastropub (Columbus) – Known for their gourmet BLTs and other creative sandwiches.  

16. The Eagle (Cincinnati) – Known for their fried chicken sandwiches with a spicy kick.  

17. The Golden Lamb (Lebanon) – Known for their historic charm and classic roast beef sandwiches.  

18. The Greenhouse Tavern (Cleveland) – Known for their French-inspired sandwiches, like the "Croque Monsieur."  

19. The Grumpy Troll (Cincinnati) – Known for their hearty pulled pork sandwiches.  

20. The Happy Dog (Cleveland) – While hot dogs are their specialty, their creative toppings make them sandwich-like delights.  

21. The Old Mohawk (Columbus) – Known for their "Turkey Turtle" sandwich with turkey, bacon, and Swiss cheese.  

22. The Pearl (Columbus) – Celebrated for their fried fish sandwiches.  

23. The Rail (Various Locations) – Celebrated for their Ohio-sourced beef burgers, which are essentially gourmet sandwiches and soo, soo good.

24. The Refectory (Columbus) – Renowned for their upscale French-inspired sandwiches.

25. The Root Café (Lakewood) – Known for their creative vegetarian sandwiches like the "Avocado Melt."  

26. The Sleepy Rooster (Chagrin Falls) – Celebrated for their breakfast sandwiches with farm-fresh ingredients. 

27. The Soulful Vegan (Akron) – Though not just a sandwich restaurant, their McVegan is the bomb. 

28. The Thurman Café (Columbus) – Famous for their massive "Thurmanator" burger, a sandwich in its own right.  

29. The Village Bakery & Café (Athens) – Known for their artisan bread sandwiches, like the "Caprese Panini."  

30. The Winking Lizard Tavern (Various Locations) – Renowned for their BBQ pulled pork sandwiches.  

31. Tommy’s (Cleveland Heights) – Renowned for their vegetarian and vegan sandwiches, like the "Tempeh Reuben."

Haven't Had Enough?

Would you like a little more info about a few of these Ohio sandwich restaurants? If so, here’s a closer look at five of these delicious sandwich spots that standout for us and what makes them so special:

1. Diamond Deli (Akron)

Located in the heart of Akron, Diamond Deli is a bustling spot known for its overstuffed specialty sandwiches. Their “pastrami on rye with Swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing” is a fan favorite. The deli also offers creative sandwich names and a variety of bread options. Beyond sandwiches, they serve soups like matzo ball soup and sides like mac and cheese. The friendly staff and generous portions make it a must-visit for sandwich lovers. And if you're in the area, tryout their Big MAC Champion Sandwich. (Link opens a new window) The roast beef sandwich with melted cheese Thousand Island dressing, lettuce, onions and pickles on a toasted brioche bun is a shout out to the Akron Zips winning the MAC championship and going on to the NCAA tournament in 2025.

2. Melt Bar and Grilled (Various Locations)

Melt Bar and Grilled elevates the humble grilled cheese to gourmet status. Their signature sandwich, the “Parmageddon”, combines pierogies, kraut, and cheese for a unique twist. Melt is also known for its eclectic atmosphere, craft beer selection, and monthly specials. Founded in 2006, it has become a beloved Ohio institution for comfort food enthusiasts.

3. Tommy’s (Cleveland Heights)

Tommy’s is a cozy spot in Cleveland Heights that caters to a wide variety of dietary preferences. Their “Tempeh Reuben” is a standout for vegetarians and vegans, featuring tempeh, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing. Tommy’s also offers hearty breakfast options, fresh smoothies, and a welcoming atmosphere that has made it a community favorite for decades.

4. Primanti Bros. (Youngstown)

Originally from Pittsburgh, Primanti Bros. has brought its iconic sandwiches to Youngstown. Their signature sandwiches are piled high with “house-made coleslaw and fresh-cut fries”, all stuffed between thick slices of bread. This unique style has made them a go-to spot for hearty, satisfying meals. Pair your sandwich with an ice-cold beer (if that’s your thing) for the full experience.

5. Swensons Drive-In (Akron)

Swensons is a classic drive-in eatery that has been serving Ohioans since 1934. While they’re famous for their “Galley Boy”, a double cheeseburger with two secret sauces, their menu also includes other sandwich options like fried bologna and BBQ pulled pork. The nostalgic drive-in experience, where the servers must run to your car when you pull up, combined with the delicious food, makes Swensons a cherished Ohio tradition.

We know you won't be able to visit every one of these Ohio sandwich restaurants, however, each of these spots offers a unique take on the sandwich experience and showcase Ohio’s diverse and delicious culinary scene. You will definitely want to add them to your list of restaurants to visit when you’re in the state of Ohio.

Don't take our word for it. Here's another list of Ohio sandwiches, and a few of them are not on our list. (Link will open in a new window).

A quick word. This page may contain affiliate links. 

Buy Now

A-B	C-D
E-F	G-H
I-J	K-L
M-N	O-P
Q-R	S-T
U-V	W-X
Y-Z