Tea Sandwiches

An Afternoon Tea

For those who love the nostalgia of a traditional afternoon tea, this image paints the perfect scene: graceful ladies in flowery hats, sipping tea from fine china, nibbling on delicate sandwiches while exchanging pleasantries. And yes, for some of us, that kind of gathering still holds its charm.  

But let’s be real—modern tea parties don’t always come with lace gloves and dainty dresses. You can just as easily enjoy a refreshing afternoon tea with a group of friends in jeans and sneakers, swapping fancy cucumber sandwiches for something with a little more variety.

Tea sandwiches are simple, elegant, and undeniably fun to serve, whether for an elaborate afternoon tea or just a casual snack. Whether you decide to stick to tradition or put a contemporary twist on your tea spread, one thing’s for sure: these mini sandwiches are delicious, easy to make, and perfect for any occasion, not just tea.

Classic Tea Sandwiches:
A Traditional Treat

If you plan a traditional tea party, there are a few key sandwiches you just can’t skip. These classics have been around for generations, loved for their subtle flavors and delicate textures:

Cucumber Sandwiches: The quintessential tea sandwich, with thinly sliced cucumbers layered over cream cheese or butter on crustless bread.  

Watercress Sandwiches: A refreshing, slightly peppery twist on tradition. Watercress pairs beautifully with a light butter or soft cheese spread.  

Pimento Cheese Sandwiches: This Southern favorite adds a bold, creamy pop of flavor to your tea sandwich options. Slightly tangy, slightly smoky, and completely irresistible. 

The key to traditional tea sandwiches is keeping them small, delicate, and easy to eat. They aren’t meant to be filling—you’re just supposed to enjoy a few bites before moving on to tea and dessert.

A Modern Twist on Tea Sandwiches

If classic tea sandwiches aren’t your thing, why not shake things up a bit with a few modern options? Today’s tea parties don’t have to stick to tradition—you can enjoy new flavors, fresh ingredients, and creative combinations that make your tea spread reflect your unique idea of what a tea party should be. 

Creative Tea Sandwich Ideas:

Mini Croissant Sandwiches – Swap standard bread for mini croissants stuffed with ham and brie, turkey and cranberry, or even a simple veggie spread.

Hummus Tea Sandwiches – Ditch the butter and cream cheese and try hummus, avocado, or Greek yogurt-based spreads instead.

Herbed Cream Cheese & Tomato – A rich spread of herbed cream cheese topped with sliced cherry tomatoes or sun-dried tomatoes make for a bright, bold bite.

Mini Pocket Pita Sandwiches – Think stuffed pita pockets with cucumber, chicken salad, or roasted veggies for an updated tea sandwich experience.

Nut Butter & Fruit Sandwiches – Peanut butter isn’t just for kids! A mix of nut butter and sliced pears or figs creates a sweet, satisfying tea sandwich.

The best part? Anything can be a tea sandwich if you cut it small enough. So don’t be afraid to get in there and experiment!

Bread Matters: Choosing the Right Base

Tea sandwiches are all about the details, and bread plays a major role in getting them just right. The tradition of removing the crusts stems from the idea that these sandwiches should be soft and effortless to eat. While you don’t have to stick with tradition, choosing the right bread will elevate your sandwiches to the next level.

Best Breads for Tea Sandwiches:

Country White Bread – Soft and classic, perfect for cucumber or pimento cheese sandwiches.  

Whole Wheat Bread – Adds a little nutty depth to your tea sandwiches.  

Rye or Pumpernickel – Ideal for open faced sandwiches with bold flavors like smoked salmon or cream cheese.  

Raisin or Cinnamon Swirl Bread – Great for sweet tea sandwiches filled with cream cheese and fruit.

If you’re looking for an extra fancy presentation, try cutting sandwiches into fun shapes using cookie cutters. Hearts, stars, or simple rounds work beautifully and will add a touch of whimsy to your tea table that is sure to be appreciated.

Tea Party Menu Ideas:
Beyond the Sandwiches

Every great tea party needs a full spread of treats, not just sandwiches. Here’s how to build the ultimate teatime menu with a balance of flavors, textures, and eye-catching presentations.

Teas to Serve:

• Classic Earl Grey – A sophisticated black tea with a hint of bergamot.  
• Raspberry Herbal Iced Tea – A fruity, refreshing twist.  
• Chai Tea – Adds a spicy warmth to balance the delicate sandwiches.  
• Green Tea with Lemon – Light and refreshing.

Teatime Desserts:  

• Shortbread Cookies – Buttery and crumbly, perfect with tea.  
• Brownie Bites – A modern touch for chocolate lovers.  
• Mini Fruit Tarts – Light and elegant with fresh berries.

Pairing the right tea and treats will turn your tea party into a truly memorable occasion. 

Hosting the Perfect Tea Party

Hosting an afternoon tea doesn’t have to be stuffy or complicated. Whether it’s just you and a friend catching up over finger sandwiches or a larger gathering, keeping things relaxed and fun is the key to a great tea party.

Tea Party Hosting Tips:  

• Set the Scene: A simple table setup with pretty teacups, small plates, and a floral centerpiece makes tea feel special.  
• Make Sandwiches Fresh: If preparing ahead, wrap sandwiches tightly to prevent drying out.
• Offer Tea Options: Not everyone loves the same tea, so serve at least two varieties to cater to different tastes.
• Enjoy Conversation: A tea party isn’t about rushing through a meal—it’s about sipping, snacking, and spending time with good company.

If you want to mix tradition with a modern twist, try serving your tea alongside charcuterie boards, fresh salads, or even themed cocktails.

Here are a few suggestions for hosting a tea party by Rosie. How to Host an Afternoon Tea Party — Rosie Loves Tea. (Link will open a new window)

Elevate Your Tea Sandwich Game

Tea sandwiches might seem small and simple, but they make a big impression when done right. Whether you’re sticking with traditional cucumber sandwiches or trying something new, the magic of an afternoon tea is all in the little details—thoughtful flavors, refreshing drinks, and an atmosphere that encourages good conversation and relaxation.

So, gather your favorite teas, whip up some delightful finger sandwiches, and host an afternoon tea you (and your guests) won’t forget.

What’s your favorite tea sandwich? Share your ideas using the form below!

I'm sure you can come up with several more sandwiches to add to our short list. And we'll also have more to add soon. If you have any suggestions, contact us here so we can add it to the list.

Want to see a video for making a high "society" cucumber tea sandwich? I know, right? Well, just watch the video below and you'll learn how to make these dainty little morsels. They'd make the perfect addition to your next tea party!

"High Society" Cucumber Sandwiches

---

Curried Chicken Tea Sandwiches

And here's a video for Curried Chicken Tea Sandwiches - looks good. What do you think?

---

California Tea Sandwiches

Here's a California Tea Sandwich video complete with avocados and sprouts.

---

Waldorf Chicken Salad Sandwiches

And one for Waldorf Chicken Salad Sandwiches. This one looks delicious!

---

A quick word. This page may contain affiliate links. 

Buy Now

A-B	C-D
E-F	G-H
I-J	K-L
M-N	O-P
Q-R	S-T
U-V	W-X
Y-Z